Four kinds of evidence show whether capability has formed
Evidence is not a record added after the work. It is the basis for judging whether the work can be done well again next time.
All four kinds must be visible:
- Execution: was the work actually performed as designed?
- Acceptance: was the deliverable acceptable?
- Uptake: did downstream work actually use it?
- Objectives: did operating outcomes improve as a result?
One successful attempt is not enough. Someone who did not participate in the design must also be able to produce an equally acceptable result using only the manual or Skill. This is reuse evidence. Without it, we cannot say “the capability has been retained,” only “it happened to work this time.”
This corresponds to “evidence” in the three principles. In the five-step consultation process, step 2 records a baseline for comparison, step 4 collects the four kinds of evidence, and step 5 tests the method through repeat execution. Only then can a decision be made to retain, adjust, or expand it.
Related reading
The five-step consultation process
Previous · 02 Why every handoff needs two judgments